Monday, December 15, 2008

Ecclesiastes


Ecclesiastes 2:20-23
So I turned about and gave my heart up to despair over all the toil of my labors under the sun, because sometimes a person who has toiled with wisdom and knowledge and skill must leave everything to be enjoyed by someone who did not toil for it. This also is vanity and a great evil. What has a man from all the toil and striving of heart with which he toils beneath the sun? For all his days are full of sorrow, and his work is a vexation. Even in the night his heart does not rest. This also is vanity.

In a former life, I worked extensively in banking. Especially in the nonprofit sector where there are all sorts of worthy causes that do a great deal of good. In this one instance, I worked on a nonprofit entity that is well-known to a particular geography in the eastern United States. The entity was struggling financially and one of the executive managers of the bank was on its board of directors. This manager had a long record of service in the bank and was highly respected for his contributions and financial acumen.

The financial condition of the nonprofit began to deteriorate and the executive tried with all his might to help this particular entity. He was personally tied to it and he genuinely wanted to see it succeed. Well, the financial deterioration increased in severity and, finally, action had to be taken to protect the bank's interest. This was done, but there was an additional caveat. A head had to roll. It turned out that this executive manager who had given so many years of dedicated and competent service was fired. To add insult to injury, there were certain ambitious young managers who gleefully and smugly approved of this "justice".

Perhaps you have seen this happen in whatever part of the world you live in. Maybe it was a coach who gave years of successful service, impacted many young lives, had a bad season and was fired immediately. Maybe it was a pastor who had a public moral failure and was subjected to a self-righteous feeding frenzy.

The givens of life very quickly destroy two naive notions: cause-and-effect and self-created identity. Cause-and-effect basically says that you will get out of a thing what you put into it. For instance, if you read your Bible, good things will happen (commonly called "magic"). If you succeed academically, you will be accepted into Stanford Law, work on Wall Street, marry the man of your dreams, and have a fulfilled life. This is a terrible myth, as the former bank executive will be quick to tell you. The empirical fact is that life will crush cause-and-effect thinking.

Another thing that dies is the idea of a self-created identity. This is baldly prevalent in the United States but it is the same in Africa or anywhere else. It is Aristotle's idea that "you are the sum of your actions" but it the idea of the natural man most profoundly. If this is true (and it is if there is no Christ) then life is "vexation" and "striving after wind" because you have to re-create your identity every day for your entire life. Even if you were to theoretically succeed, the end of your life comes and you are quickly forgotten. Your gains are distributed among others and the whole process begins anew.

In this short devotional, I invite you to despair of cause-and-effect thinking and self-creation. Receive, instead, the perfect and unconditional gift of eternal love through our Savior Jesus Christ.

8 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Cause and effect thinking for work tasks are needed in order to get the hungry child off the streets. There is a process of sharing the love you experience to others. Through the system and tasks the child may begin to experience unconditional love and be ready to hear Christ. There is a joy in doing these kind of work tasks that may make the work tasks more Christ like. However it is a thin line to be crossed if this work task becomes less important to the individual than herself/himself.

11:29 AM  
Blogger David Browder said...

My point is that cause does not equal effect. The proof is that there actually still are hungry children on the streets and those who have heard the gospel but have not experienced the unconditional love it offers.

My proposal is not depair and quietism, but an understanding that cause equals effect only in the case of God who is the only one who has the control necessary to bring it about.

When this is realized, then doing things like getting hungry children off the streets can be done for the long-term in a sustainable frame of mind rather than ending abruptly in frustration.

1:23 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Well, yes, there is no connection between reading the Bible every day and good things happening, but I can say that every time I read Ontological Goo (well, every time there is something new to read), a good thing happens ipso facto.

All kidding aside, thank you for this--as usual--very helpful comment.

8:57 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Sometimes it feels as if God is taking a long time. And instead of getting mad at God sadness is a feeling different from despair and is expressed by many aware of cause not equaling effect. I sometimes think that God has tears. That may be too sentimental but it helps me feel closer to God.

9:42 PM  
Blogger David Browder said...

Walter, I must apologize to you and my other readers who have not seen a lot of new material lately. I have had a difficult time lately reading and thinking creatively. My mind has been very cloudy recently and insights have not come as readily as in the past. Hopefully, this will change soon.

Anonymous, I agree with the God having tears part. I totally disagree with Barthian top-down theology which says God does not feel pain. Jesus said "he who has seen Me has seen the Father" and Jesus both wept and sweated blood at Gethsemene. I don't think it is sentimental at all in the pop sense. I think it helps one live this life to know that.

1:29 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

This is an interesting and complex topic. If we look throughout Paul's letters we see "cause and effect" warnings intermingled with the gospel message of personal helplessness and the perfect righteousness of Christ applied to the unworthy sinner. It seems that Paul, and several of the other NT writers, see the hard fact that we do live in a world of "cause and effect", to the extent that "if you do these things you will die", but that this fact is not meant to be a motivating factor in our relationship with God, whom we love because He first loved us, not because we fear the consequences. But that is a gross oversimplification of the richness of the many NT texts that ebb and flow in this area. I John is also a very interesting book on this subject.

4:25 PM  
Blogger David Browder said...

Speaking of cause/effect, how are you and Beth doing?

4:50 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

We are doing well. I am back at work. Beth is still home recovering. We are both glad it's over, and look forward to a year of less dramatic "cause and effect."

6:02 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home